2007年6月12日火曜日

The baby hatch

I want to talk about baby hatch today. It is the worldwide problem these days. There are many countries that place the baby hatch. It is interpreted in a good way and a bad way. People say the baby hatch violate the law ,such as the prevention of child abuse and child welfare.There are different opinion about the baby hatch. I read a few opinions about it.


Letter One
In contrary opinion, the writer uses the example about the people who are disable adults. She is warning that abandoning a baby is the problem not only for his parents but also for everyone. She supposes the idea about the connection of the parents and children. Also, she writes her feeling that she felt when she heard the assertion. She explains what the Japanese is like and she does not think that if we make the baby hatch, all baby are saved.


Letter Two
In favorable opinion, the writer shows the example of the couple of junior high school students. She thinks that they had no idea after the baby was born because of fear. So she insists that she does not know but if there was the baby hatch at that time, they might use it or if they did not use it, their fear and anxiety were decreased by knowing the existence of the baby hatch. Their baby might receive the medical care. By existing the baby hatch, the parents reconsider about abandoning their baby.


My opinion

I agree to placing the baby hatch because some life are saved by it. It is better to saved the life than the baby dies. Actually, many babies were saved in other countries. The purpose of baby hatch is keeping the babies so the parents can come back to take back them if they regret abandoning them. The parents would decide to give up raising their baby after sufficient consideration. The baby hatch might be the system which accept the deserted children but it is more important to protect them quickly and safely.

There are some instances about the baby hatch. We are very sad when we hear the news that someone is killed. On the other hand, when we hear the news of saving a life, we are more happy than hearing the sad news. Therefore, it is a better way to place the baby hatch.

However, the parents should not abandon their baby. Using the baby hatch is the last way. They need to consider before giving up raising their baby. As long as the parents are delivered of the baby, they must bring up him with responsibility as parents.

This is why I agree to place the baby hatch.

4 件のコメント:

phillip さんのコメント...

checked! (Your second link doesn't work....)

suguru さんのコメント...

I agree with you. Surely "Baby Hatch" is good way to protect children and perarents shouln't abandon their children. However, I want to insist the importance of stopping abandoning babies than placing "Baby hatch."
I think you've summerized the two letters well.

Ippei さんのコメント...

I agree with you. I also baby the hatch should be the last choice to be taken.
Your opinion in the last paragraph impressed me strongly.

mami さんのコメント...

Although I agreed with Letter1,your opinion is also true.
Baby hatch helps children who are dying.As you wrote,Baby hatch is the last way for parents.I think most important thing for parents is comprehension how much important their children are.